In his debate with William Lane Craig, Sam Harris lodged the forceful objection against Christianity (and Islam) that, according to its doctrines (as he misunderstands them), millions of people will go to hell for being born into the wrong culture at the wrong time. What he means is that those born into, for example, predominantly Hindu or Islamic cultures will be less likely to ever come to accept the truth and forgiveness offered by Christ's redemptive and salvific work on the cross and in His resurrection, than someone who was born into a predominantly Christian culture.
While this is, in a sense, true, it's an incomplete picture of the situation and it is represented with a particular narrow rhetoric that doesn't do justice to reality. Once a few things are clarified, the poverty of this particular representation of the situation becomes clear.
First of all, simply being born into a Christian culture will curry you no favor with the Christian God. Many people who are raised Christian, and even many who consider themselves Christian, in the vaguest sense, are not actually Christian. Then there are many who are born into Christian cultures but reject Christianity. And -- something I sometimes forget about myself but was reminded of when I re-read The Screwtape Letters recently -- even a true Christian can sometimes fall away from the faith (not that that happened in Screwtape, but the simple fact that Screwtape's "subject" was a Christian reminded me).
Secondly, given the global spread of Christianity, there are many people in all cultures who are now Christian. Not to mention that what were once the "right" places for being born Christian, such as France, are increasingly becoming (or have become) places where you're much more likely to be raised secular and godless than many villages in Africa where you are now more likely to be born and raised Christian. So the picture is much more ambiguous and muddled than merely being born into the "right" or "wrong" culture.
Thirdly -- though perhaps this should have been my first point -- according to Christian beliefs, all people are guilty of sin, the wages of which are death. If someone goes to hell it wasn't because of which culture they were born into, but because they sinned against God, and because they rejected -- not didn't hear, but rejected -- the gracious rescue by Christ from sin and death.
Now, as to the supposed injustice of it being easier for those born into a Christian culture to come to knowledge of, and commitment to, Jesus Christ, this is probably true. Christ came to rescue all humanity and open the way to God for all people, yes, but he did this knowing that many people (and cultures) would reject him. If that seems "unfair" to our modern (and perverse) cultural lenses, who ever claimed fairness (in our modern sense) to be a divine attribute? We claim that God is just, and justice for the guilty means death. Death means separation from God and hell. That is what everyone deserves. God would have been perfectly just to leave us in our death. Anything humanity is given that is greater than death and hell for all is an act of Grace. Something no one deserves, but which you may either accept or reject.
The fact that God seems to make the conditions for following him "easier" for certain peoples isn't exactly inconsistent with his character as revealed in the Bible or as understood by Christian doctrine. The God of the Old Testament was the God of Israel, His chosen people, to the exclusion of the other peoples of the world. God also annihilated human life on the whole planet except for Noah and his family. While we may find this act more palatable because Noah was a relatively righteous man in a wicked world, he was still a sinner whom God could have also justly eliminated. But God had mercy on him. The situation is no different from today, only it isn't a "relative goodness" or a "smaller wickedness" that Christians possess, as Noah did, but a perfect righteousness that is imputed to Christians via Christ's substitutionary work of atonement on the cross. The sins of those who trust in Christ are washed by His blood and they are made new in His resurrection. Not because they were born into the right culture, but because they placed their faith in Him and accepted the only salvation available to the guilty. And this way is open to all the people of Earth.
Whether or not one accepts the truth of this narrative, the question that's pertinent here is whether or not it makes sense to impugn God's character as unjust or unrighteous. If it did, then that would be a legitimate objection to a faith that claims that God is just and righteous. And this was Harris' point; if the God of the Bible is real, then He is "unjust" or (really) "unfair", because the God of the Bible doesn't fit our modern American model of fairness. He had a chosen people, and even when He graciously opened the way for all people to Him, it's still a truth that is easier for some to accept than others. Shouldn't he make it equally easy or difficult, to be fair? And if He claims to be just and righteous but isn't (again, according to our faulty model of what it means to be just and righteous), then He either isn't actually real after all, or He isn't worthy of our allegiance because He's discriminatory (and a discriminatory God is unacceptable to our cultural tastes).
Once the objection is seen for what it is, it carries no weight whatsoever against the truth or consistency of Christian belief, although one could see how it might resonate with the values of our culture. If God were actually "playing favorites", that would be his prerogative and we would have no legitimate complaint against it as we deserve nothing but death. But, viewed in the correct light, there's no reason to conclude that anyone is ever treated unjustly, even granting that people born in certain cultures will more readily accept Christ, and others will more readily reject Him.
Our God is a discriminating God. There are things that delight Him and things He finds abhorrent. He bestows blessings and curses. He has a people. He has a Kingdom. He has standards. We all fall short of those standards and must either accept or reject His Gracious offer of Christ's blood as a means of reconciliation. Being born into the "wrong" culture is no excuse.
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Tuesday, December 13, 2011
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Troy Davis and The Death Penalty
Not to be a downer, but I'm pro-death-penalty and (more importantly) pro-justice-system, especially in cases where there is absolutely no evidence of racism or misconduct of any kind, as in the recent case of Troy Davis.He recieved a fair trial by his peers and numerous fair appeals in the light of questionable 'new evidence'. None of which was enough to satiate racial antagonizers and America-haters everywhere. From the NAACP and Al Sharpton to Ammesty International and Big Boi, many opposed his execution up to the last minute. But would they have done so if the facts were the same but the 'victim' was white? There's no reason to think that they would and ample reason to doubt it, casting negative racial aspersions on the entire movement's true motives.
In the short run, being in favor of the death penalty is difficult. Emotions and even one form of reason ('killing this person won't bring back the dead or deter others') are fully on the opposong team. Regardless of the deterrent effect, it is logical to support the state's right to weild the death penalty and execute it when appropriate. Has a dead criminal ever been at risk of recidivism? No, and so the death penalty is completely competent at keeping specific criminals from committing further crimes themselves. Whether it keeps others from commiting crimes is a secondary consideration, if any.
To quote Steven Pinker in The Blank Slate:
As Oliver Wendell Holmes explained, “If I were having a philosophical talk with a man I was going to have hanged (or electrocuted) I should say, ‘I don’t doubt that your act was inevitable for you but to make it more avoidable by others we propose to sacrifice you to the common good. You may regard yourself as a soldier dying for your country if you like. But the law must keep its promises.’” This promise-keeping underlies the policy of applying justice “as a matter of principle,” regardless of the immediate costs or even of consistency with common sense.
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Osama and Death Celebration
Many of the Christian blogs and posts on social media sites that I've been reading over the last few days have shared a common theme; either one of struggling with the proper response to the news of Osama's death, or simply renouncing the celebration of his death that many Americans are participating in, while citing scriptural reasons for this (Ezekiel 33:11, Ezekiel 18:23, Prov. 24:17 etc.). I'm not sure that I fall into either of these camps.
In my mind, there's a distinction to be made between enemies of yours, as an individual, and how the Bible says you are to treat them -- turning the other cheek when they wrong you (Matt. 5:39), loving them (Matt. 5:44), clothing and feeding them (Rom 12:20, Prov. 25:21), not wishing death upon them etc. -- and how governments should respond to their enemies. The Bible teaches that the governments of Earth are ordained by God and wield the sword as an instrument of God's authority and judgment on Earth (Rom. 13:1). The commandments to us, as individuals, about how to treat our enemies don't apply to enemies of the government in the same fashion.
I didn't consider Osama bin Laden a personal enemy of mine to begin with. Did you? I never met the man nor had I ever met any of his victims. I always only considered him an enemy of my country and an enemy of civilization at large, and as such I saw that it was important to stop him if we could. Not as a matter of vengeance, which the Bible teaches belongs to God alone (Rom. 12:19), but as a matter of justice and as a matter of protecting the citizens of our nation (and others) from this person's murderous reign of terror.
Is it improper, then, to root for my government to wield the sword wisely and carry out justice? Is it only acceptable to do so before they succeed at it? The instant that they succeed, must I then become sorrowful that they did in fact succeed? If I am holding my attitude for the right reasons, if I'm not delighting in my heart at the demise of a human being, then I see no reason I should not celebrate the success of my nation acting as the duly appointed administer of divine justice that it is.
This, admittedly, is a fine line. At what point does my celebration of the achievements of the brave men and women who defend this nation become a matter of unearned personal pride in my heart? Am I really only celebrating the act of justice, the achievements of the heroes, the relief at a threat to civilization being defeated, or do I harbor a personal satisfaction in another human's death? Certainly it's difficult to keep the matters properly separated in our hearts and minds. Because of this I think it's appropriate for Christians to either make quite clear exactly what it is that they are celebrating -- and that it isn't someone's death, but the bravery of the troops, the relief for families, the increased security of the nation, the lives ultimately that will be saved etc. -- or to simply not celebrate at all.
The only reason I felt compelled to address the issue is in response to those who condemn the act of celebrations as necessarily entailing the celebration or delight in the death of a fellow fallen human, which doesn't follow necessarily. There are many things in this news and its implications worth celebrating, the death of a human being just isn't one of them. The death of Hitler entailed that many fewer human beings in Germany would be mercilessly slaughtered because of their ethnic and religious heritage. I would argue that if you don't celebrate this consequence of the death of this particular human being -- though not the death itself -- that this refusal to celebrate would itself be a quite grave sin.
In my mind, there's a distinction to be made between enemies of yours, as an individual, and how the Bible says you are to treat them -- turning the other cheek when they wrong you (Matt. 5:39), loving them (Matt. 5:44), clothing and feeding them (Rom 12:20, Prov. 25:21), not wishing death upon them etc. -- and how governments should respond to their enemies. The Bible teaches that the governments of Earth are ordained by God and wield the sword as an instrument of God's authority and judgment on Earth (Rom. 13:1). The commandments to us, as individuals, about how to treat our enemies don't apply to enemies of the government in the same fashion.
I didn't consider Osama bin Laden a personal enemy of mine to begin with. Did you? I never met the man nor had I ever met any of his victims. I always only considered him an enemy of my country and an enemy of civilization at large, and as such I saw that it was important to stop him if we could. Not as a matter of vengeance, which the Bible teaches belongs to God alone (Rom. 12:19), but as a matter of justice and as a matter of protecting the citizens of our nation (and others) from this person's murderous reign of terror.
Is it improper, then, to root for my government to wield the sword wisely and carry out justice? Is it only acceptable to do so before they succeed at it? The instant that they succeed, must I then become sorrowful that they did in fact succeed? If I am holding my attitude for the right reasons, if I'm not delighting in my heart at the demise of a human being, then I see no reason I should not celebrate the success of my nation acting as the duly appointed administer of divine justice that it is.
This, admittedly, is a fine line. At what point does my celebration of the achievements of the brave men and women who defend this nation become a matter of unearned personal pride in my heart? Am I really only celebrating the act of justice, the achievements of the heroes, the relief at a threat to civilization being defeated, or do I harbor a personal satisfaction in another human's death? Certainly it's difficult to keep the matters properly separated in our hearts and minds. Because of this I think it's appropriate for Christians to either make quite clear exactly what it is that they are celebrating -- and that it isn't someone's death, but the bravery of the troops, the relief for families, the increased security of the nation, the lives ultimately that will be saved etc. -- or to simply not celebrate at all.
The only reason I felt compelled to address the issue is in response to those who condemn the act of celebrations as necessarily entailing the celebration or delight in the death of a fellow fallen human, which doesn't follow necessarily. There are many things in this news and its implications worth celebrating, the death of a human being just isn't one of them. The death of Hitler entailed that many fewer human beings in Germany would be mercilessly slaughtered because of their ethnic and religious heritage. I would argue that if you don't celebrate this consequence of the death of this particular human being -- though not the death itself -- that this refusal to celebrate would itself be a quite grave sin.
Wednesday, April 27, 2011
On "Social Justice"
What is "social justice" and how does it differ from normal justice? Courts adjudicate matters between people living in a society under a particular social contract. Is this not "social" enough to be considered social justice? And if that is "social justice", then why even add the "social"? Why not simply talk about justice, since old fashioned formal justice is already inherently social? Why did someone feel the need to create this term?
Last year Ryan Messmore wrote an article on the origin of the term. The term and concept seems to have originated with the writings of Luigi Taparelli D’Azeglio who was an Italian Jesuit scholar. What Taparelli meant by "social justice" was that governments should recognize and respect various spheres of social life -- families, churches, organizations -- without disrupting or usurping them. He held that these ground-level associations were of primary importance whereas formation of states and countries were of secondary importance, and that the latter should be built upon the foundation of the more fundamental former. True justice only can come about when these social associations are preceding and feeding into the government. This conception of "social justice" I have no problem with, and it seems to me that he is completely right. I might quibble with his choice of words used to coin the phrase, but if this is what people meant when they said "social justice" -- which essentially entails government yielding much of its claimed territory to more intimate social entities -- then I would be entirely in favor of "social justice".
Though, the origin of the phrase doesn't interest me as much as its popular usage and what people mean when they use it today. All kinds of people use the phrase -- environmentalists, politicians, Christians -- and it means slightly different things depending on the context, but in almost all cases it doesn't mean what it originally meant nor does it seem to add anything to the cause that is being advocated, but rather is often just a rhetorical tool used to appropriate the moral or intellectual high ground by force.
For example, in American politics the term is used almost exclusively as a euphemism for wealth redistribution. This is by far the most prevalent use of the phrase today. When it's used in this way the term's literal meaning is inverted. It is not just for the government to use coercion and force upon one individual or group of individuals to benefit another group of individuals. This is unjust, and when it isn't the government that is doing it, we imprison individuals for it and call it theft and larceny.
Not only that, but this is in direct contrast to what Taparelli meant, as it steps upon all intermediate social spheres of life and appoints the government the final arbiter of "social justice". Friends, families, soup kitchens, churches, local health facilities, private charities etc. should be primarily responsible for administering "social justice" through their own free will as collections of individuals. It is lazy and an abdication of duty to prescribe this job to the government, and it empowers the government to use coercion and force on groups of individuals whom it should not be exercising force upon. This is literally the opposite of "social justice" in every conceivable sense.
Yet the left squawks about "social justice" 24-7 and the right -- who is actually in favor of formal justice (which is social), as well as the "social justice" that Taparelli advocated -- never uses the term. I see why they don't because it has been appropriated by the left to mean something alien, but we on the right would do well to at least make it quite clear, as often as we are able to, that there is no "social justice" in wealth redistribution or in the tyrannical usurpation of freedom. And if the left wants to advocate wealth redistribution, then make them do it using language that actually fits the deed. "Social justice" doesn't belong to the left. The left doesn't even know what it is.
Last year Ryan Messmore wrote an article on the origin of the term. The term and concept seems to have originated with the writings of Luigi Taparelli D’Azeglio who was an Italian Jesuit scholar. What Taparelli meant by "social justice" was that governments should recognize and respect various spheres of social life -- families, churches, organizations -- without disrupting or usurping them. He held that these ground-level associations were of primary importance whereas formation of states and countries were of secondary importance, and that the latter should be built upon the foundation of the more fundamental former. True justice only can come about when these social associations are preceding and feeding into the government. This conception of "social justice" I have no problem with, and it seems to me that he is completely right. I might quibble with his choice of words used to coin the phrase, but if this is what people meant when they said "social justice" -- which essentially entails government yielding much of its claimed territory to more intimate social entities -- then I would be entirely in favor of "social justice".
Though, the origin of the phrase doesn't interest me as much as its popular usage and what people mean when they use it today. All kinds of people use the phrase -- environmentalists, politicians, Christians -- and it means slightly different things depending on the context, but in almost all cases it doesn't mean what it originally meant nor does it seem to add anything to the cause that is being advocated, but rather is often just a rhetorical tool used to appropriate the moral or intellectual high ground by force.
For example, in American politics the term is used almost exclusively as a euphemism for wealth redistribution. This is by far the most prevalent use of the phrase today. When it's used in this way the term's literal meaning is inverted. It is not just for the government to use coercion and force upon one individual or group of individuals to benefit another group of individuals. This is unjust, and when it isn't the government that is doing it, we imprison individuals for it and call it theft and larceny.
Not only that, but this is in direct contrast to what Taparelli meant, as it steps upon all intermediate social spheres of life and appoints the government the final arbiter of "social justice". Friends, families, soup kitchens, churches, local health facilities, private charities etc. should be primarily responsible for administering "social justice" through their own free will as collections of individuals. It is lazy and an abdication of duty to prescribe this job to the government, and it empowers the government to use coercion and force on groups of individuals whom it should not be exercising force upon. This is literally the opposite of "social justice" in every conceivable sense.
Yet the left squawks about "social justice" 24-7 and the right -- who is actually in favor of formal justice (which is social), as well as the "social justice" that Taparelli advocated -- never uses the term. I see why they don't because it has been appropriated by the left to mean something alien, but we on the right would do well to at least make it quite clear, as often as we are able to, that there is no "social justice" in wealth redistribution or in the tyrannical usurpation of freedom. And if the left wants to advocate wealth redistribution, then make them do it using language that actually fits the deed. "Social justice" doesn't belong to the left. The left doesn't even know what it is.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
The Efficacy of Incarceration
Thomas Sowell has a new blog post that lightly touches on the subject. Sowell delves more in depth into the subject in his most recent book Intellectuals and Society. As you might expect, if you know anything about Sowell, his (and my) belief is that incarceration, especially as traditionally practiced in the United States, is a good and effective thing. Not because of it's ability to rehabilitate, but because it is effective without rehabilitating.
Leftists have attempted to move the goal posts with regards to incarceration using all kinds of secondary, or irrelevant, criteria for evaluating it's efficacy. Criteria such as "how well does it rehabilitate?", "how well does it deter?", "how much does it cost?" etc. How well it rehabilitates or deters are at best secondary considerations, and if it does neither, but succeeds at reducing crime by simply keeping criminals off the street, then it is very effective at what it is primarily supposed to be effective at. As for cost, statistics citing the enormous cost of incarcerating criminals, which liberals tend to spew at every given opportunity, are actually largely irrelevant because they are rarely, if ever, presented in the context of what incarceration costs versus the cost of having those criminals let loose in society. There is much evidence that suggests that the costs of incarceration are less than those potential costs of releasing thousands of criminals into the streets (or failing to incarcerate them in the first place), and Sowell lists some of those evidences in his book.
Some potent evidence for the efficacy of traditional incarceration practices are the witnessed results of alternative philosophies of incarceration, namely focusing on prevention by getting at "root causes" and seeking to "rehabilitate".
Liberals often cite recidivism rates as evidence that "incarceration doesn't work." Which is only evidence that incarceration doesn't work that well at reforming criminals, but reforming criminals is not the primary goal of incarceration. The primary goals of incarceration are protecting citizens from criminals and decreasing the amount of criminal activity that takes place in society. Anything else is extracurricular, and often focus on these extracurriculars can detract from the main goals. Sowell writes:
Some more reasonable liberals will object something along the lines of "Well, OK, but aren't some sentences too harsh? Doesn't America incarcerate too many people, and for too long?" Which is a legitimate question to ask, and there certainly is a theoretical threshold at which one can go too far with a policy. But I don't think we've reached that threshold as crime is still too high, and incidents of unjust, excessive incarceration, or of unjust laws, are fairly low. Though, with that being said, I don't necessarily think all of our resources are optimally directed at this time. That is, there's probably too much focus on minor drug offenders, for example. So certainly our system is not perfect. It's just the best.
Liberals will also list anecdotal evidences of 'unjust' sentences for minor crimes, like the third strike offender whose third strike was stealing a pizza. Often concluding that some mandatory sentencing law, such as the three strikes law, is too harsh. Because it can result in people who commit three nonviolent crimes serving very long sentences. I fundamentally disagree with the notion that this is unjust because I think a proven repeat minor criminal has higher potential to be someone who commits a serious crime. Or, minimally, will continue to commit minor crimes costing society a lot to get hurt by them, catch them, judge them, jail them, release them, catch them, judge them, etc. ad infinitum. Everyone deserves a second chance. And a third. But not much more, at least from society (from each other as individuals and from God is another matter). Not to mention that liberal defense lawyers, and their ilk, right after decrying the injustice of a third strike life sentence for a nonviolent offender, will make the same argument on behalf of a rapist or a child molestor. These people's objections should be taken very lightly.
Even if I did recognize some anecdotal examples of unjust sentences, that doesn't even begin to make the case that the entire system of incarceration is unjust. Any functioning justice system will have instances of injustice, injustices done to both criminals and their victims by the way (the latter examples of injustices being conspicuously missing from such lists). The task is minimizing, not eliminating, these injustices. And we do an excellent job of that already.
Leftists have attempted to move the goal posts with regards to incarceration using all kinds of secondary, or irrelevant, criteria for evaluating it's efficacy. Criteria such as "how well does it rehabilitate?", "how well does it deter?", "how much does it cost?" etc. How well it rehabilitates or deters are at best secondary considerations, and if it does neither, but succeeds at reducing crime by simply keeping criminals off the street, then it is very effective at what it is primarily supposed to be effective at. As for cost, statistics citing the enormous cost of incarcerating criminals, which liberals tend to spew at every given opportunity, are actually largely irrelevant because they are rarely, if ever, presented in the context of what incarceration costs versus the cost of having those criminals let loose in society. There is much evidence that suggests that the costs of incarceration are less than those potential costs of releasing thousands of criminals into the streets (or failing to incarcerate them in the first place), and Sowell lists some of those evidences in his book.
Some potent evidence for the efficacy of traditional incarceration practices are the witnessed results of alternative philosophies of incarceration, namely focusing on prevention by getting at "root causes" and seeking to "rehabilitate".
In the United States, where murder rates had been going down for decades, and were in 1961 less than half what they had been in 1933, the legal reforms of the 1960s - applying the ideas of the intellectuals and widely applauded by the intelligentsia - were followed almost immediately by a reverseal of this long downward trend, with the murder rate doubling by 1974. In Britain the ascendancy of the same vision of crime was followed by similarly sudden reversals of previous downward trends in crime rates. As one study noted:
Scholars of criminology have traced a long decline in interpersonal violence since the late Middle Ages until an abrupt and puzzling reversal occurred in the middle of the twentieth century
Liberals often cite recidivism rates as evidence that "incarceration doesn't work." Which is only evidence that incarceration doesn't work that well at reforming criminals, but reforming criminals is not the primary goal of incarceration. The primary goals of incarceration are protecting citizens from criminals and decreasing the amount of criminal activity that takes place in society. Anything else is extracurricular, and often focus on these extracurriculars can detract from the main goals. Sowell writes:
In Britain, as in the United States, it is often taken as axiomatic that "prisons are ineffective," as The Economist put it. The reason: "They may keep offenders off the street, but they fail to discourage them from offending. Two-thirds of ex-prisoners are re-arrested within three years of being released." By this kind of reasoning, food is ineffective as a response to hunger because it is only a matter of time after eating before you get hungry again.
Some more reasonable liberals will object something along the lines of "Well, OK, but aren't some sentences too harsh? Doesn't America incarcerate too many people, and for too long?" Which is a legitimate question to ask, and there certainly is a theoretical threshold at which one can go too far with a policy. But I don't think we've reached that threshold as crime is still too high, and incidents of unjust, excessive incarceration, or of unjust laws, are fairly low. Though, with that being said, I don't necessarily think all of our resources are optimally directed at this time. That is, there's probably too much focus on minor drug offenders, for example. So certainly our system is not perfect. It's just the best.
Liberals will also list anecdotal evidences of 'unjust' sentences for minor crimes, like the third strike offender whose third strike was stealing a pizza. Often concluding that some mandatory sentencing law, such as the three strikes law, is too harsh. Because it can result in people who commit three nonviolent crimes serving very long sentences. I fundamentally disagree with the notion that this is unjust because I think a proven repeat minor criminal has higher potential to be someone who commits a serious crime. Or, minimally, will continue to commit minor crimes costing society a lot to get hurt by them, catch them, judge them, jail them, release them, catch them, judge them, etc. ad infinitum. Everyone deserves a second chance. And a third. But not much more, at least from society (from each other as individuals and from God is another matter). Not to mention that liberal defense lawyers, and their ilk, right after decrying the injustice of a third strike life sentence for a nonviolent offender, will make the same argument on behalf of a rapist or a child molestor. These people's objections should be taken very lightly.
Even if I did recognize some anecdotal examples of unjust sentences, that doesn't even begin to make the case that the entire system of incarceration is unjust. Any functioning justice system will have instances of injustice, injustices done to both criminals and their victims by the way (the latter examples of injustices being conspicuously missing from such lists). The task is minimizing, not eliminating, these injustices. And we do an excellent job of that already.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)